Saturday, November 21, 2026

Nightfall (Devil's Night, #4) by Penelope Douglas Review


This review contains spoilers - read with caution. You can read my reviews of Corrupt, Hideaway, Kill Switch, and Conclave on my blog, now!

Can someone PLEASE explain to me why this book was over 700 pages?? I am at a utter loss on why we were put through a literary saw trap for this couple, especially when it was basically the most low stakes story of the four couples. That being said, Will is the most emotionally stable (if you can even call him that) of the bunch and actually used some of his brain cells in this book - a major improvement compared to the other buffoons we dealt with in the previous installments. He has a mildly correct moral compass and is not actively terrorizing Emory at every chance he gets and with the historical run these boys have thrust upon all the other girls, this is considered chivalrous.

I never thought I would see the day that one of these basketball playing hooligans actually used a brain cell yet here we are. Apparently if you live in Thunder Bay you are legally required to have a low IQ or a lack of common sense. Will is truly the only one in this group that seems to use some semblance of logic when creating a plan or trying to woo Emory, and compared to what the other boys did to get their girls, it makes you want to give him a prize. Sure, Will definitely had his moments and considering what he participated in the past he is not the most law abiding citizen, but he is a yearner. That being said, he nearly had me locked in until the very end with the comment to Damon about Winter, saying "You got her fixed, right?" after she just gave birth to what seemed to be their thousandth child. Any respect I had for him flew straight out the window.

Every single time that readers are reminded that Rika is the mayor I have to let out a laugh, as it was outlandish the first time it happened and it will continue to be outlandish for the rest of time. It is just an utterly ridiculous plot device that only makes sense in the land of Thunder Bay and would be considered preposterous in any other series except perhaps in the world of Saint View High series by Elle Thorpe. 

On the topic of insane things that transpired in this series, we need to talk about the way Emory mentioned that she did not mind Martin beating her up because that meant she got to go to school and see Will... who thinks like this?? I was literally perplexed by this statement and had to backtrack and make sure I read it right. Her brother was actively abusing her and yet somehow it got turned into Emory yearning for Will across the hallways instead of a look into how horrible her home life was. She basically lived every minute on edge and even notes that the calmer days had her anxiety through the roof since she never knew when the switch would flip. I am glad that Martin met his end, but it surprised me that the topic was never addressed beyond a couple of conversations.

The quadruple wedding at the end... I laughed so hard that I had tears streaming down my face. It was actually absurd in every sense of the word and was something so silly for this gang of criminals. I cannot even begin to form a complete reaction to it - the second all of the girls revealed the matching rings for the boys, I lost all composure. To be completely honest, even though Will and Emory make a decent pairing, there was such a huge underlying tension between Damon and Will that it was glaringly obvious and would have been great to explore. Maybe it is because I am not fond of Damon and Winter together, or maybe it is because Will and Damon have seemingly been dancing around one another this entire series, but there definitely is something between them. Do we all remember what was revealed in Kill Switch??

We could have knocked off 300 pages from this book and I think the same things would have been accomplished, and while the past and present perspectives certainly added to Will and Emory's characterizations, they felt overwhelming at times. I do find it interesting that the other installments had the characters going through some absolutely insane events, this "final" one did not go as out of the park as I expected from Douglas.


You can add Nightfall on Goodreads now, and follow the author to stay up to date on releases and publications.


You can catch up with me and my current reads by friending me on Goodreads and following this blog, my Twitter (X), and my Instagram in order to stay up-to-date with any reviews, blog tours, and more!

No comments:

Post a Comment