This is a spoiler-free review! The version I am reading is an ARC - any changes made for the final publication are not reflected in this review. Black Wings Beating is available to purchase as of September 25, 2018.
My ARC pile is starting to fear me as I tear through the quite literal tower of books in my apartment in an attempt to de-clutter and finally crack them open. This young adult fantasy definitely feels more mature than most - we see a number of instances where the male lead, Brysen, basically goes through The Horrors with the way his father treated him, along with the serious consequences of the world and environment he lives in. The female lead, Brysen's sister, Kylee, seemingly has the better end of the stick compared to her brother, and with her more natural calling to falconry and forming bonds with the birds despite her will to be free of it altogether, we see her destiny become more bright than Brysen's current state. While Brysen seemingly has a knack for impulsivity and leading with his emotions, Kylee is more reserved and level-headed - as they are close to finally paying off the debts their father left their family behind, they must be strategic.
The flashback scenes with the abuse that Brysen suffered at the hands of his father was sickening - to see such atrocity being inflicted on a boy for making small mistakes, or even in some instances, some major mistakes, was nauseating. Kylee certainly tried her best to remove Brysen from the path of pain, but she could only do so much when he was not in her line of sight. It seemed the second he was not in her direct view, there was always something that was going amiss.
While war looms over their lives, Kylee and Brysen find themselves on a hunt for the Ghost Eagle, they are confronted with their own personal interests and conflicts. As Brysen's quest is motivated by the boy he adores from the village and the glory that would come with capturing the Ghost Eagle, Kylee is determined to preserve her brother's future and leave her past behind for once and for all. I found Brysen to be so incredibly annoying - so much so that I had to push myself to finish the second half of this book before I threw it off the skydeck at my apartment building. He never seems to take anyone else's fate into consideration and is clearly solely motivated by glory rather than seeing the bigger picture. The fact that Kylee basically has to manipulate events in order for him to be remotely successful should tell you everything about their characters.
Kylee, on the other hand, seems to be the only person in this village with working brain cells, which is very concerning considering a war is literally crawling up the mountain at this point. She is reasonable and while on occasion a touch erratic, sees the bigger picture and only wants the best outcome for her brother that does not leave them drowning in more debt than they started with and him, well, still breathing. She had much more to tackle in this book - with all of the obstacles she had to overcome in addition to basically having to watch and babysit Brysen as he "attempted" to catch the Ghost Eagle - it was surprising that Brysen still thought Kylee was not on his side.
The pacing of this book threw me off - at times it moved at what seemed like a glacial pace while other chapters felt like I was being whipped around and could get a glance of what was happening before perspectives shifted or we were somewhere else. I was hoping that the maturity of this series would allow the story to be more complex, but considering curse words were replaced with made-up curses, I should not have been surprised. The ending did not have the build up that I was expecting and while the "betrayal" was significant for a character in particular, I saw it from a mile away. Maybe one day I could return to this series, but for now I am content with leaving the story here.
You can add Black Wings Beating on Goodreads now, and follow the author to stay up to date on releases and publications.
No comments:
Post a Comment